Tuesday, April 16, 2019

Is Baker Mayfield as Smart as Tom Brady?

Now that Russell Wilson signed a new conract for an average of 35 mil/year, people are trying to guesstimate what Baker Mayfield's second contract will look like.

...I don't want to think about it.

Let me tell you something: Everybody says "you should get as much as you can" as if it's a moral imperative.  They turn themselves into pretzels saying Tom Brady didn't really take less money; pointing out that his supermodel wife is richer than he is---as if he could never have afforded to take less money otherwise---it's bizarre...

What planet do you guys live on!??  They play a children's game for a living, and make ten to 100 times as much as you do!  He needs a rich wife to SETTLE FOR more than brain surgeons make!?!

Here's the deal: Tom Brady took less money than he could have gouged for so that the Patriots could afford better players, and this is partly why he keeps going to Superbowls (and remains healthy).

Every other quarterback dons a ski-mask and hollers "stick 'em up!!!" and gobbles up over 15% of his team's salary cap, and usually his team never does much after that, as guys like Myles Garrett, Nick Chubb, Callaway, Njoku, Ogunjobi, Randall etc leave in free agency because the team can't AFFORD them anymore!!!

I know blah blah arrogant blahblah cheater (wha-eva) but if a quarterback wants to WIN more than he wants more money than he (or his descendants) can never spend, he takes less.

It's not even a sacrifice, really!  When you win Superbowls, people want to pay you multi-millions to make commercials and stuff!

Flacco.  Rodgers.  Cousins (he just took his cap-hit to a new team).  Check out which Quarterbacks (aside from Brady) reached the last five Conference Championships and Superbowls.

How smart is the good-looking, polarizing Baker Mayfield?  Is he as smart as Tom Brady?  Clearly, he wants to WIN, more than anything else.

Is Baker smart enough to accept a little less money from the Browns so the Browns can retain and acquire other players to help him win, so he can do commercials and make more money anyway on his way to the Hall of Fame?

Odds are against it, but there is a glimmer of hope: Mayfield really is not a sheep.  He will ignore the peanut gallery...

Speaking of which, I'm amazed by star linebackers, edge-rushers etc on various teams always saying that their Quarterbacks should "get all they can get"...

...then expressing shock and disappointment when their team "let" them "go" for some inexplicable reason.

Russell Wilson is the highest paid player in the NFL.  I can't congratulate him, because he'll probably never reach a Conference Title game again, and has no shot at the Hall of Fame.

You people don't get this:  There IS NO moral imperative to gouge for every last penny.  That's called GREED, and it's selfish.  With due respect for my bro E, it's a union mentality.

In the free market, the smartest people make the most money and accrue the most awards.

Tom Brady took less money from the Patriots than he could have.  Rodgers, Flacco...

Check out this list per the Bleacher Report:

In general the old (overpaid) Quarteracks didn't get that far, and the number one QB was Mahomes.

The underpaid Tom Brady won the Superbowl over sophomore Jared Goff.

Drew Brees and the Saints got screwed by the refs in a F I X, so that doesn't count; however, the Rams were extremely talented because Goff didn't gobble up 16-20% of the Rams cap space (yet).

Sure, Lord Insideous has everything to do with the Patriots dynasty, but so does Tom Brady, who is now massively underpaid I mean...is Russell Wison really TWICE as good as he is?

Why isn't Brady raising hell?

...is any of this sinking in yet?





Sunday, April 14, 2019

2019 Browns Taken Seriously. Except By Cowherd...Who MEANS IT

From behind enema lines, Steeler writer Bob Labriola wrote a terrific article in which he questions the Browns' annointment as the favorites to win the AFC North.

Bob and I could probably debate this (over beers) for hours, because he is objective.  He considered all the factors fairly.

I couldn't really find much wrong with his analyses; in fact have written much of the same stuff myself.

But I can pick on Bob a little:

1: For all the games since Freddie Kitchens (the liberator) took over, Baker Mayfield outperformed Big Ben (with a 108+ QBR).

2: The Steelers did have the best passrush last season, pre-Vernon and Wilkinson, and while Avery and Chad Thomas were rookies.  This will probably change in 2019.

3: The Steelers DO still have the best offensive line, and that's vital, but:

The Browns will have the better Wide Receivers, defensive line, and probably secondary.

Leaving Bob Labriola, I need to re-address this "sophomore slump"/defenses figuring out quarterbacks stuff in re Baker Mayfield in more detail:

Defensive coordinators look for situations in which quarterbacks look bad.  Now, with the help of people like PFF and Numberfire, they can read that data on EVERY snap the quarterback has played, so they can see stuff like:

How he does running left, vs right.
How accurate he is on crossing, vs vertical routes.
Does he hold the ball? Can he be confused?
Does he lose accuracy and strength in motion?  Does he have to have his feet set?
Can he deliver DEEP?
To the sidelines (on a rope)?

Most young quarterbacks have expoitable weaknesses that show up in PFF's intricate numbers and on tape.

Baker Mayfield does not.  That's not "fandom".  It's a confirmed fact.

His shorter stature actually helps him, as he has better balance and takes shorter steps than the taller guys; he can bend and twist to execute powerful and accurate throws running to his left.

Wilson and Brees are shorter. Rodgers and Mahomes are less than an inch taller. See how that works?  Of course, most of it is psychological and mental.

Elliot Kennel thinks the Browns are the most talented team in the NFL, and if you are laughing, slap yourself out of it.

I include the link out of respect to Elliott, but you won't find much that I haven't already told you here.  But Kennel digs deeper and cites sources; he's more organized and thorough than I am.

That's why we now know that NINE current Browns have been Pro Bowlers.  N I N E IX 9.  And NONE of these nine is past his prime.

And in listing all the studs on this roster, Elliott left out Njoku.

That might be a meaningful omisson (got u, Elliott):

After initially dropping passes and stuff as a rookie (and early in his second season), David Njoku became a "money" receiver as soon as Baker Mayfield took over for Tyrod Taylor.

In fairness to Tyrod, David dropped some perfect passes from him.  But something about Baker Mayfield just...made Njoku more reliable.  I understand this intuitively, but don't have the words to write about it yet.

...anyway, John Dorsey "called" Njoku "out" in public for his mediocre pass-blocking, and Njoku replied "Challenge accepted"

As I have posted,  Freddie Kitchens ran two (and sometimes three)-tight end offenses in 2018.

These personnel packages were important in neutralizing edge-rushers (and making Hubbard/Robinson look better in pass protection than they were).

Njoku excelled in run blocking, but screwed up too often in pass protection.

This is common for the new breed of tight ends who are really supersized Wide Receivers.

When "in-line", when a pass is called, they are expected to "chip block" a DE or OLB towards the Tackle, then go out for a pass.

These tight ends don't pay nearly as much attention to opposing edge-rushers as they do to the guys who will be trying to cover them as they do their film-study homework.

They also tend to think that giving an edge-rusher a "shove" before going out for a pass is good enough.  They don't pay enough attention.

If the edge guy stunts inside, they don't look for the safety or corner coming from the outside.  Sometimes, their "chip" blocks barely effect the edge-rusher at all, and they go into a pattern leaving the Offensive Tackle beaten.

Per PFF, Njoku was a good run-blocker but a bad pass protector in 2018.  I have almost zero doubt that (thanks to Dorsey's public critique), David Njoku will be a REAL Tight End in 2019.

Most of you don't get this yet:

OBJ is here now, along with Landry.  Then there's Callaway.  Monken/Kitchens will want all 3 on the field as often as possible (with Njoku, of course duh).

Well, that's a spread offense.

David Njoku will NEED to swallow his pride and protect his quarterback as he targets other guys.  John Dorsey just made damn sure he WILL.

Elliot Kimmel is brilliant, but not perfect.

David Njoku (as a REAL Tight End, as well as a supersized wide receiver) will be critical in 2019.

I'll get more into that later, if I live that long. 










Friday, April 12, 2019

Day 3 Sleeper, Bad Analysis, Dumb Articles, Dorsey, and the Browns

The guys on PFF Radio really like this draftable linebacker: Te'Von Coney (Notre Dame).

Seems counter-intuitive for "analytics guys" to like a guy with sub-optimal size, speed, and explosiveness much, but here's why they do:

Coney was the surest tackler (by far) in this draft, at any position.

This isn't my first Coney reference, as I posted about him a couple months ago, and compared him (mentally) to Joe Schobert.  He plays with discipline, and rarely makes a mistake.  And now I know, if he gets two hands on you, you are probably going down.

As the pretty good linked scouting report says, the Devins and a couple other linebackers outclass Coney physically, and you don't want him man covering anybody, but he DOES stuff the run, and (again because he's so smart) does well in zone coverage (as he anticipates breaks and reads the quarterback as well as any free safety).

Steve Wilks could make good use of this guy, and from day one.  The PFF guys felt he would be worth a second or third round pick, but kinda expect him to go in the fourth round or lower...where Dorsey will be waiting with his basket.

To be clear, he's probably a situational and depth player here, as he's mainly a middle or inside linebacker, and that's Schobert's thing.

Randy Gurzi says that certain PFF writers are lukewarm on the Mayfield/Beckham combo.

Randy doesn't get it either.  They talk about a higher average depth-of-target, but Mayfield was way up there in that category in 2018, and Monken won't change that.  Nor is Beckham a one-trick pony; nor will he dominate the targets.

Some PFF writers, as I've said, are writers first, and not real analysts.  They cherrypick stats and data to support their pre-determined premises, which are based on hunches and "feelings".

This guy has a hunch that Mayfield will lose ground in 2019, because most second year quarterbacks do.

But he is using season-long 2018 stats; not even separating the Haley offense from the Kitchens' offense.  This guy works for PFF, and is using season-long grades to rank and anticipate Mayfield 2.0.  

That's just plain incompetent.  As Randy notes, much of what this guy said was vague and subjective ("just cuz").

More competant analysts at PFF understand that Baker Mayfield is not a guy defenses can "figure out" and stifle by watching films.

Hell, that's why they agreed with Dorsey that he was the best QB in the 2018 class!  He had no discernable weaknesses!

AND they make sure to separate Mayfield/Haley from Mayfield/Kitchens.

But the OBJ downgrade was just inexplicable:

As a competent PFF writer noted, Baker Mayfield is a more accurate (and persistant) deep thrower (measured by "yards per-attempt" and completion percentages at various ranges) than Eli Manning.

OBJ is now THE Browns' deep threat, so why would HE decline with Mayfield in a Monken/Kitchens offense!?!

You might suspect that this really bad analyst might have accidentally been right about OBJ's step back but no:

In addition to Sterling Shephard, Eli also threw a lot to Saquon Barkley and Engram.  

Because Eli's offensive line was weak in pass protection, Shurmer used OBJ as a deep decoy a lot and hit these other guys underneath a lot to get the ball out of his hands.

Barkley, Engram, and Shephard are no slouches.  The Browns offensive line and quarterback are better, and OBJ will NOT be a decoy when he goes deep!

Jake Burns lists a bunch of Offensive Tackles who should be there in rounds 2 and 3.  Meh.

Dan Justik lists three Dorsey draft-day trades; two up and one down.  He got Chris Jones, Kareem Hunt, and Patrick Mahomes.

'Nuff said?

Randy Randy Randy! Gurzi wrote an article listing 3 players that might be worth a trade-up...and all three probably go in the first round!!!

He even talks about one guy going in the late TEENS! 

So sad.  I think if Dorsey had ever traded away most of a draft to move up 20 slots, Justik would have found it.  Why is Gurzi wasting time with this?

I'm depressed now.  Okbye.




Thursday, April 11, 2019

John Dorsey is Only 18 Slots Away From the First Round!!! Trade Imminant!!!

You people.  If you ask John Dorsey if he would consider doing anything, he will say yes.  So yes, he would consider trading back EIGHTEEN OR MORE SLOTS into the first round.

If it was free.  Because if it's not, it would cost him the rest of his draft picks, so stifle that idiocy, ok?

Dorsey needs every draft pick.  He's already got several "balloon payments" (Garrett,  Schobert, Ojunjobi, Njoku, Callaway, Ward, Mayfield etc) and has depleted much of his cap space.

Damarius Randall enters his contract year in 2019, as well, and he's got to be a priority.

Kareem Hunt is on a one-year contract, and there's no way he won't at least try to re-sign him (so he can trade him).

As another very smart writer described a few weeks ago, Dorsey's approach should be very effective in the short term, but is not sustainable.  The Colts are building a roster that looks like it will outlast Dorsey's, and that's because Colbert has stuck to the draft.

Dorsey isn't dumb.  He gets this.  He's siezed an opportunity to go for all the marbles in 2019/20, but knows he needs to pay for it.

Fortunately, John Dorsey does better than most GMs on Days 2 and 3.  He can find his Averys, Hunts, Hills, Callaways etc and get some youngsters in the pipeline to replace the veterans he'll lose in free---

Oh nevermind cuz he's gonna trade back up into the first round!  Sorry my bad.

Jeez...

Dorsey will also need to dump some overpaid veterans, including Hubbard and Kirksey.  (The Hubbard contract is the main reason I decided OT is a need after all).

Anyway, John Dorsey might move up in the draft to nab a slider he wants, but eighteen slots isn't realistic in this realiity, or on this planet.

Damon Sheehy Guiseppi is probably an underrated dirt-cheap signing.

The Browns need microscopic slot receivers like they need a hole the head, but this 4.38 speedster is a hellacious punt returner, and Dorsey is going out of his way to upgrade special teams talent this offseason.

Damon's story is kinda like Kurt Warner's; you just root for this guy.

Alonzo Highsmith is really the guy who noticed Guiseppi and no doubt bought him to Dorsey's attention.

Ideally, this guy can return both kicks and punts, and maybe help in coverage as well.  I'm rooting for him.

All the mock drafters seem to agree that Terrence Mitchell and both the safeties Dorsey just signed suck, as they mock safeties and corners to the Browns in the second round.

While the players these guys "pick" for Dorsey all look pretty good, and would certainly help, secondary is NOT the need these goobers think it is.

I can now give you my updated reality-based priority list (I mean beyond "best available player" period):

1: DT.  You need to ROTATE these guys, and there isn't enough depth there.

2: OLB.  Kirksey is massively overrated/paid.  Adarius Taylor is as good as Kirksey, which aint sayin much.

Despite the fact that under Wilks, 3 real linebackers on the field at the same time will be a rare phenomenon, as-is it's Schobert, Rodney Averyfield, and guys named Joe.

3: CB: A TALL one.

4: Offensive Tackle.  Dorsey needs to dump salary, and Hubbard (like Kirksey) is a way to do that-plus Robinson will get too expensive to re-sign.

This order is not etched in stone, and doesn't trump best available.  This draft is not (neccessarily) for 2019.  It's for depth and embryonic talent that can emerge 2-3 years down the line to replace veterans lost to the salary cap.

The Peanut Gallery doesn't grok the fact that Defensive Tackles take a horrific beating, and any 4-3 defense needs at least THREE GOOD ones to make it through games and the season...

Nevermind.  Ogunjobi just faded out in 2018 cuz he's a "quitter" or something...excuse the hell outta me :!@×₩%;?!%+*!!?!




Wednesday, April 10, 2019

Mentally Impaired Browns "Analysis" vs Intelligent Analysis. No Contest.

Lots of dummies don't get this, but Paul DePodesta is still here, and is substantially responsible for everything that is happening with the Browns.

Dumb people love absolutes, since balancing shades of gray make their heads hurt.  Dorsey is great, ergo Brown and DePodesta sucked. 

Really, Chief Strategy Officer Paul DePodesta's strategy of an unapologetic rebuild and stockpiling draft picks and money set Dorsey up.

Dorsey executed stage 2 of DePodesta's plan, as Sashi Brown would have, had he not been fired.

If you think that the DePodesta plan had no such payoff in mind, you need a brain transplant.

Verily, Sashi the Cap guy/lawyer couldn't have pulled off the trades Dorsey did--he doesn't have those relationships, and Dorsey is also a better judge of talent than the geek squad.

But Baker Mayfield over Darnold?  Paul was definitely all on board with that (like I was), because his analytics said Baker was much better, period.

I'm not sure about Denzel Ward over Bradley Chubb, but I can tell you that DePodesta wasn't upset.

...anyway, DePodesta right now is trying to restrain Dorsey's spending on upper-tier veteran free agents.

It's not as bad as most pundits think it is, however:

Chris Kirksey is beloved, but not a good player.  You guys don't seem to get this, but John and Paul do, and may have already replaced him with Adarius Taylor, who is equally mediocre and lots cheaper.

He's one example.  

I'm also starting to warm up to this drafting an offensive tackle idea, since if Greg Robinson plays well in 2019, the Browns can't afford him, and Hubbard is overpaid as-is.

Des Harrison is still here, and remains a better athlete than everybody in this draft class, but does indeed have a lot to prove, and can't be counted on.

Campen is getting a bead on that kid now.  Is he bigger, or just fatter?  Campen can tell how hard Des worked in the offseason-hence how dedicated/disciplined he is...

Anybody who reads this Blog groks that with this quarterback and in this offense, the pass-blocking of the offensive tackles aren't as important as they used to be.

This is why Greg Robinson is as good as gone.  Because Mayfield is rarely 7 steps deep, gets rid of the ball so quickly, and is so slippery, Robinson will look awesome again.

DePodesta gets this stuff.  Dorsey seems to as well.  Some fool will pay Robinson like he's Joe Thomas II and he's a GMF.

Hubbard is not an ascending player, and is overpaid.  

Newly acquired veteran Kendall Lamm is servicable (nobably in pass-protection) and much, much cheaper...but not a long-term answer...

So yes, Dorsey should consider offensive tackles in this draft...especially since replacing Hubbard ('s salary) in 2020 has to be a priority.

Anonymous Browns-Bashers are quoted as saying that the analytcs guys who never left (read DePodesta) will be "in the owner's ear" and (I guess) mess everything up.

Well, everything you've read here was analytical.  Exactly where would "football guy" Dorsey disagree with any of it?  And why do these cretins expect any conflict at all?

These guys are "NFL execs" really?

The dumbest analysis of the Browns' 2019 prospects I've heard so far consisted of a pundit listing Mayfeld, the last half of 2018, Beckham and the other additions, BUT:

"The Browns' history is what it is.  We have seen this before.  So we need to pump the brakes on this".

They PAY these people to spew this STUPORTITIOUS bullcrap!!!  This idiot cites owners, coaches, and players who are retired or dead to indict Mayfield, OBJ, Garrett, Lan---everybody just because they wear some version of the same UNIFORM as a bunch of guys they never even MET!?!

THIS is why we should "pump the brakes"!?!

These people are allowed to VOTE!   The Idiocracy is already here!

I rest my case.

For now.












Saturday, April 6, 2019

2019 Browns Doomed. Dysfunional Collapse Imminant. Good Grief

This Browns-bashing is getting really silly, especially from Colon Cowherd, who has now just gone off the rails.

A big part of this bashing has to do with the impression a lot of these east and left coast types have of Cleveland itself.

They think Cleveland is Green Bay, or Bismark North Dakota or something.  Far too boring for the likes of OBJ.  

This is ignorant, and I know.  I've been all over this country, and Cleveland is far from the Siberia these goobers think it is.

Sure, OBJ likes shiny things, crowds, and noise a lot more than I do, but hell, we got a casino downtown, two blocks from the flats.  We got the lake.

It's hard to match New York and New Jersey for tolls, taxes, and traffic jams, but there are spots around Cleveland where an ex-Giant can find those too.

These people are selling Cleveland way short, and, too, perhaps OBJ himself.

His freindships with Landry and Mayfield are being "overblown", really?

Don't you think Jarvis Landry (who came here from Miami) knows how his brotherfromanothermother feels?  Why would Landry lobby to bring this guy he loves here if he thought OBJ wouldn't be happy in Cleveland?

This "control-freak" charge with Haslam and Dorsey is pretty ignorant too.  Jeez Haslam says "let's go get him" in re Manziel and suddenly he's a meddling micromanager!?!

And Dorsey?  Well he's a General MANAGER, right?

Oh yeah!  Per Cowherd, Freddie Kitchens' elevation had nothing to do with his merit, right?  Dorsey just wanted a puppet who he could control!

Wow just...wow.  He expects Kitchens to be in "over his head" as Landry, OBJ, and Mayfield will push him around or something.

All this drama these people are trying to drum up for the Browns!

Leaving the Soap writers and gossip columnists behind, SS Morgan Burnett's new contract is for two seasons with significant guarantees.

Burnett is unmistakeably expected to start in 2019.  Clearly, Steve Wilks feels he's a good fit for HIS scheme.

As I posted yesterday, Dorsey has safety (and possibly the secondary) covered in-depth with Murray and Burnett *WILKS NOT WILLIAMS*.

The Genard Avery unintenional bashing is stunning, as pundits echo eachother wondering if he can eventually become more than a situational passrusher.

Avery was a LINEBACKER in college!  He blitzed a lot, but he also covered and blew up runs.  When the hell did all these pundits decide a 250 lb guy with 4.5 speed and outstanding agility scores is a "project" linebacker?

AVERY is a question mark, but not Kirksey!?!

Per PFF, the rookie Avery was better than the veteran Kirksey already (and Kirksey SUCKED, by the way)...

Anyway OLB is a need, but Avery is going to start (and excel)...it is Saint Kirksey who is on the bubble...here in the real world.

Defensive Tackle is the number one need on this roster. Linebacker is second.  (Tall Wilks-freindly) DB third.  Offensive tackle is fourth.

Dorsey will probably go best available throughout.  

The final roster will not be perfect.

Welcome to Reality.






Friday, April 5, 2019

Browns Pundits/fans are NOT all that Knowlegable, and so are you...or something...

Former Steeler Morgan Burnett is now regarded by most local pundits as the early front-runner to replace Jabrill Peppers (and Derrick Kindred at Strong Safety, because...

...well he was a Steeler and was a former third round draft pick...I guess...

PFF Grades: Overall Burnett 66.7, Murray 67.5

Vs pass B 62.8, M 66.9

Vs run B 69.8, M 71.2.

It's true that John Dorsey was part of the Green Bay crew that drafted Burnett in the third round, and also that (like the rookie Peppers) Burnett was playing free safety rather than strong last season, so he probably does have the inside track.

From what I hear, as a SS with the Packers, he was a pretty good player, so returning to his comfort zone under Steve Wilks should elevate his numbers over those he showed last season.

But people are ignoring both Burnett and Murray, and mindlessly proclaiming Strong Safety a priority in the Draft.

Actually, Murray is a versatile player who can play several positions in Wilks' 3-deep.  While not very fast or sudden, he has a Schobertian nose for the ball (he reads and reacts quicker than most defenders), especially in coverage.  

Ideally, enough talent gets in front of Murray to render him a situational player, utility depth, and special teams ace, but you could do a lot worse than this guy as your Strong Safety, ok?  Get real.

Burnett was, per PFF, pretty close to Murray while playing deep last season, and should indeed be at least as good as he was as a Packer (which was pretty good) at Strong.

Yes, they lost a really good (and improving) player in Jabrill Peppers, and no, niether Burnett nor Murray look as promising as Peppers, but why do you automatically think that every loss has to be replaced by an equivalent or superior player?

That's Utopian.  Sure, Dorsey would love not to lose any ground ever anywhere on the roster, but he (*DePodesta*) has to deal with the real world:

Peppers was the second "first round pick" Gettleman wanted for OBJ.  He didn't want to trade him, but deemed OBJ as good enough that he was willing to take the hit...to accept a downgrade at one position for a more significant upgrade at a more important position.

He traded a "9" Strong Safety for a "10" Wide receiver.  Now, he has added two "7" Strong Safeties, and yes...may have to scrape by with them.

It's called a "trade-off", Virginia.

GMs need short memories.  John Dorsey has taken a minor hit at SS in order to get a major upgrade at Wide Receiver, and does NOT consider SS a priority (rule of thumb: when the playerS at any position are above average, that position is NEVER a priority in the real world.)

On this planet, the real priority needs John Dorsey faces are, in order:

1: DEFENSIVE Tackle depth.

2: A tall (matchup) cornerback.

3: Best available.

As you see, Strong Safety is not included.  This is because Dorsey/Wilks's current roster includes two above average Strong Safeties DO YOU UNDERSTAND?

The current Browns secondary (with Wilks in charge) is adequate (and deep).  ...errah...do any of you get that Wilks aint Gregg Williams yet?)

Zinggg I'll have to redundationalize this in a future post...but for now, you have to admit that I am a genius, since I beat "utilize" by 4 syllables.

I rest my case.