The signing of J T Hassel (undrafted) went right by me, but I caught up with this FREAK now.
I'm not talking about his birth defect (which doesn't seem to bother him at all), either. In addition to his 4.36 40, Hassel jumped 42", ran a 4.26 short shuttle, and (I think) a sub-6.8 3-cone drill.
Even at 6', 200 lbs, that's off the charts, folks!
J T won't play linebacker in the NFL at that size, of course, but whoever compared him to Derrick Kindred was pretty smart.
Hassel played for a micro-college, so it's hard to really get a bead on him in coverage, but with those physical traits, it's very likely he'll become better than Derrick in that role.
Another smart guy also mentioned that Steve Wilks, like Gregg Williams, likes to use a safety/linebacker hybrid type player. I hadn't known that, but it gives Hassel a much better chance of making the final roster in 2019.
Seriously, I don't know why, aside from his malformed left hand, this kid had to play for the Little Sisters of the Poor.
I haven't seen his hand, but it sounds like he only has two of his four fingers. I guess they work, however, as he made five interceptions and forced a ton of fumbles. I also saw him take down a couple quarterbacks left-handed on his highlight tape.
Dorsey and his scouts were smart enough to just ignore the hand, and good for them.
T J Hassel will, I predict, make the final roster.
In addition to his freakish athleticism, I've read several analyses which describe a very intelligent player, with Joe Schobert-like instincts and anticipation. Hassel is always at or near the ball when the whistle blows, even though opposing offenses avoided him like the plague.
He's a lock to be a star special-teamer on every coverage unit. The Browns now have a lot of safeties (and cornerbacks), but Wilks is expected to rely heavily on back end players, and will likely carry ten or more DBs.
Everybody assumes that Hassel will be a "safety", but that's a label. T J has all the requisite tools to play cornerback; especially in off-man or zone (see "Wilks, Steve").
This is another reason why this guy will make this team: He can play ANY position in the secondary.
It's not realistic to expect T J to make a big impact (on defense) in his rookie season, but with his "football intelligence" and explosiveness, he's also a long way from a "project", regardless of where he played in college.
Remember reading this a couple years from now, people: T J Hassel, if not injured or something, should be not just a starter, but a star.
Digging up guys like these is critical for John Dorsey right now. He's already looking at Damarius Randall and Greg Robinson prepping their Brinks trucks for the 2020 offseason, and it will be impossible for him to keep everybody he wants to keep.
I know you people all agree that the Browns need to keep Damarius Randall, but you're not GMs.
Redwine, Hassel, and a cornerback or two are possible replacements for Damarius Randall.
Greg Robinson is even more likely to hit the dusty trail after 2019, as his Mayfield/Kitchens/Tight End-aided pass pro stats will inflate his percieved value beyond sanity.
His ideal potential replacement is unmistakeably Rodney Harrisonfield, and that might work out perfectly.
It's possible that Harrison will elbow Robinson out of his way this season, but probably more likely that Robinson's experience and consistency keeps him in place for 2019.
This would give Des Harrison a chance to refine his skills without pressure for another season.
Many (including me) have suggested that Harrison could challenge Hubbard at Right Tackle in 2019 as well, but I have to back off on that:
In my last post, I went into the whole rleft side to right side" transition thing in re Austin Corbett's slow progress at Right Guard.
Corbett was a 4-year starting Left Tackle in college. Harrison actually started for roughly one season, and that at a lower level of competition.
Campen and company will probably (and should definitely) let Des Harrison focus exclusively on Left Tackle.
Oh you guys are bored, right? What about Baker and OBJ and Garrett right? Well see that's why a more disciplined and better organized version of me could be a GM and you couldn't. Deal with it.
The sausage is made in the trenches, by the "grunts" fans don't notice. While you've been sleeping, John Dorsey did an amazing job of "deepening" the Offensive line with proven NFL starters (each and every one above average in pass protection).
Meanwhile, here comes Todd Monken, so (thank God) all G-power Hue Jackson/Haley stuff is 80% out the window now...
Long story, but the Cliff Notes version is that zone-blocking is simple, and doesn't require overpaid human bulldozers. Also, it screws up defenses, because it looks like pass-protection at the snap.
Obviously, I'm repeating the Run/Pass Option stuff yet again, but since nobody ever gets it, I have to repeat it:
If you have an explosive one-cut running back, a decisive, smart, and accurate Quarterback, and receivers who "uncover" early, you need to run RPOs.
RPOs make edge-rushers kinda useless, as it takes too long for them to get around the Offensive Tackles.
The zone-blocking massively helps so-so offensive linemen succeed in run-blocking as it's idiot-proof, and extremely difficult for defenses to counter without taking huge risks (ie shooting gaps and leaving soft spots...you don't want me getting into that trust me).
Long story short, with a Mayfield and these skill-players, a "journeyman" Offensive Line (strong on pass protection) will work just fine.
Like they did and do for the Shanahans, and other coaches that zone-block.
Anyway (sorry) Des Harrison only needs to become competent to replace moneybags Williams, and if Austin Corbett craps out, his seasoned veteran replacement will be at least adequate.
Is any of this sinking in? John Dorsey is exploiting RPOs and zone-blocking to save money on the Offensive Line (like the Shanahans do).
This will help him spend more on the skill players and defensive studs he needs to keep around.
Are you getting this? Kevin Zeitler was worth every penny of his huge salary, but for a zone-blocking team, a much cheaper journeyman would work nearly as well.
Paul DePodesta John Dorsey saved a ton of money--or more accurately "reallocated funds" out of Offensive Line and into Defensive Line and Wide Receiver.
And trust me: John Dorsey is talking to the coaching staff daily about their players. He wants to know how Des Harrison looks, because it's possible he can trade Robinson and his salary if Harrison is deemed a viable starter in 2019 (as unthinkable as that sounds, since Harrison is a bust, right?)
Under DC Steve Wilks, the Browns are indeed unlikely to field 3 real linebackers more than once in a blue moon.
Now that this has dawned on Captain Obvious, maybe it will occur to you that I was right in calling those who called linebacker depth a big issue dumbasses.
Duh. But even now that this is dawning on the punditry, they're managing to misninterpret what that means...you people really need to check with me first, you know?
Anyway, that doesn't neccessarily mandate a 4-man front, Sherlock. Wilks has and will use dime defenses at least half as often as nickels.
The "fronts" he uses are flexible too, as he can use "stand up" DE's with 2-3 real down linemen, line up a Garrett etc inside in a "Nascar Package".
My guess right now is that Steve Wilks will use Takitaki and Avery to spell the real DE's on obvious passing downs, and shift his DT/DE hybrids inside to relieve Ogunjobi.
And he will probably blitze more than he has in the past (mostly inside) to get at least 4 passrushers into the mix.
The yokels also miss on the linebackers. Even smart guys like Randy Gurzi keep talking about Christian Kirksey as if he was an elite linebacker at any point in his carreer.
The DePodestian model is not sentimental. Avery, Takitaki, and probably at least one more linebacker are better than Kirksey ever was.
Well it's late. This concludes my dissertation. There will be a quizz in the morning.
Okbye.
Doug Lesmerisis wrote about what he's seen during the first few days of OTAs, including how Austin Corbett is looking.
Doug kept repeating repeatedly "it's very early", but based on the reader comments I read, I'm one of a very few who read that part, and I'm sure Doug himself is stunned.
Doug says that the Coaches are "all over" Corbett, correcting his hands and feet, while taking the rest of the guys for granted.
Certainly, this makes me nervous, but like Doug said over and over and over again, it's still very early.
I wrote about how difficult it is for players to move from the left to the right side of the center, and this is part of Corbett's problem.
I know that last season he was working at center and guard, but don't know if he ever worked at right guard. Even if he did, he got limited reps there.
Austin Corbett played nothing but left tackle for most of his life. He came to the Browns hard-wired to do everything the opposite of the way he has to do it now.
His body wants to lead with the wrong foot, and use the wrong hand...can't you see how these reversions might be what is making Campen yell at him? Playing on the right side still feels unnatural to him.
Nah, I'm not saying to forget Doug's critique because Corbett can't miss. I'm nervous about this, too; especially since Doug said that 2019 draft pick Forbes looked about the same as Corbett.
But oh, those comments!!! Corbett is a bust already! He sucks! Jeez you people...wow.
Anyway, John Dorsey brought in a whole bunch of insurance, with two solid veterans with a lot of starting experience. Ideally, Austin Corbett gets the hang of RG and wins the starting job, because he's the guy with elite upside. But there is a backup plan, ok?
Genard Avery was lining up at DE (with his hand in the dirt), but I strongly suspect that this was experimental. Avery doesn't have the length to come out of a 3-point stance and engage 6'6" Offensive Tackles, but might have the first step to get under their pads, like Elvis Dummerville.
Doug saw him mainly with the third teams, and not at all at off-the-ball linebacker.
I wouldn't read too much into that. Unlike with Austin Corbett, I'm certain that Steve Wilks and company are experimenting with a bunch of defensive players in various roles to get a feel for their unique skill-sets.
Probably every team with a new DC and scheme do this during the first few days.
Correction: Genard Avery was not exclusively a stand-up passrushing DE in college. He lined up all over the place, and was in coverage a fair amount of time (sufficient for PFF to give him an above average coverage grade).
The Avery at DE experiment is informative, however. Steve Wilks is quite prepared to use smaller, faster guys on the edge, at least situationally, and wierd fronts.
Takitaki was a Defensive End until his final college season, by the way. Avery is an inch shorter, but heavier and stronger, so they're probably trying to figure out if he can do Takitaki stuff.
That's part of building a Defensive scheme. You try to have at least two players for each niche-role, so you don't have to delete a section of your playbook if a guy gets injured.
Predictably, Rodney Hilliardfield has predictably improved a lot since his first rookie season (shocking, I know!)
Obviously, in shells the runs mean nothing, but the pass-catching really does mean a lot, and Dontrell is winning a lot of battles against some pretty damn good coverage.
John Dorsey didn't draft Duke Johnson, folks, and WILL trade him the instant he gets a solid offer. Dontrell Hilliard is here to replace him.
Binniss is binniss.
Undrafted CB Jhavonte Dean had an impressive first day, but has been "quiet" since.
He still has a good chance at making the final roster due to his great athleticism, stature, and traits.
Like Rodney Ratleyfield, Dean is a beanpole (6'2", 185 lbs), and can probably get pushed around by the big receivers he'll need to cover, so he's probably going to take some time to develop.
But he's incredibly fast; possibly faster than Ward. Once Hans and Franz pump him up, Jhavonte Dean should compete for playing time (probably in 2020).
CORRECTION: The 2019 Browns will NOT use 3 Wide Receivers "almost exclusively".
I know that Todd Monken is an "Air Raid" guy and Baker was an Air Raid Quarterback, but Freddie Kitchens is in charge now.
In 2018, Kitchens used up to 3 RBs or TEs a lot (and very effectively). Baker Mayfield thrived.
Monken also is a big Run/Pass Option guy, and that requires a legit running game. That almost always means at least one tight end, and often a second running back or tight end.
Check out the offseason signings; count the tight ends (including those who can play fullback), and please note that running backs who can't catch passes down field need not apply here.
Certainly, with these top 3 Wide Receivers, the 2019 Browns will use all 3 at least half the time, but dammit, words mean things, and when you say "almost exclusively", you are lazy, hazy, and...well I would never hire you to paint my house, because I don't want to be scraping paint off my WINDOWS and like my shrubbery alive, ok?
Idiocracy. Seriously. It gets dumber every year.
John Dorsey let Darren Fells go, but signed Demetrius Harris to replace him. Harris is a BLOCKING Tight End. Orson Charles is a blocker first. Seth DeValve is trade-bait first, but a FB/H-back second.
Psst! Shhh! Gregg Robinson? He aint all that, see? See, Mayfield got ridda da ball quick, or scrambled and made big plays on da run, see? And shhh...but see, dis Kitchens...he uses Tight Ends to chip deze edge-rushers, see?
Don't tell nobody you hoid it from me, see?
Seriously, it's not a secret. It just SEEMS like one, because nobody else (except a couple guys on NFL Radio) comprehend this.
CORRECTION: Baker Mayfield is "sophomore slump"-proof. Terry Pluto was pretty lame, as he said that Mayfield is dedicated and obsessed (and terminally pist off), so it wouldn't happen to him.
I REPEAT: Baker Mayfield has no weaknesses for defenses to exploit. He doesn't even have any tendancies. The best you can do is "herd" him to his left, because he's right-handed.
I suppose you could try to trap him in a pocket and hope he can't see anything over the skyscrapers in front of him, but other than that, Baker Mayfield has no exploitable weaknesses.
Quarterbacks catch "sophomore slumps" when opposing Defensive Coordinators discover that he throws it away (or forces it) vs inside pressure, is less accurate to the short right side, hesitates on deep passes to the right or left corner, tends to hold the ball, etc.
If you didn't have Stockholm Syndrome, you would agree with the national guys (except Colon, of course) that Baker Mayfield is already a top 10 NFL QB, and will be even better in 2019 than he was in his rookie season.
DUH.
CORRECTION: If Austin Corbett isn't good enough to start at Right Guard, it's not a disaster.
Kush and Kalis are proven veteran starters; both well above average in pass-protection.
They're below average as run-blockers, but the Kitchens/Monken offense will zone-block a lot, and rely heavily on the instincts of their running backs.
That's not a "throwaway line", you people: Even if your right guard isn't a great athlete, it's the running back who makes it work, and the 2019 Browns are eyeball deep in one-cut running backs.
...well I'll explain further yet again later, but for now, a zone running back runs at a (downhill) angle towards the sideline, and has no specific hole to hit. He simply looks for "daylight" in the chaos in front of him, and when he sees it, darts into it (or accellerates outside if that's all he's got). Ebineezer Bell is the ideal zone running back---even though the Steelers man-blocked a lot--but Bell is the best example I could find.
Now, Hue Jackson (and maybe Todd Haley too) was a cave man. He insisted on "G-Power" man-blocking, no madder wudd.
Full circle: If Austin Corbett doesn't start at RG, it's not a disaster. The other guys are terrific pass-protectors, and the Browns' exceptional running backs can overcome weak blocking from a specific position...
Aw dammit the ideal zone-blocking guards are genuine athletes who can find and neutralize linebackers in space, see?
But ALL Offensive Linemen can execute "step one", and engage a Defensive Lineman (or occasionally a linebacker).
Step 2 is (sometimes) releasing (handing off) the blocked defender and going upfield linebacker-hunting.
Well, often the guards who excel in pass protection can do ok as inside zone blockers. They're nimble, and athletic.
Corbett is the best athlete, and (hysterical permabasher bullcrap aside) a powerful run-blocker, but this offense should work almost as well if one of Dorsey's veteran journeymen start at RG instead.
Rodney Harrisonfield is still here, but obviously Greg Robinson has set the bar impossibly high.
Bullshit. If you have written Desmond Harrison off, you need a brain transplant. For that matter, don't assume that Robinson is trade-proof in 2019, either.
...Oh sorry. Confused? Shocked? Why?
I get it: YOU think Greg Robinson is why Baker Mayfield was sack-proof for much of 2018.
Nah! In case my earlier comments here (and previous posts) zinged over your head, Freddie Kitchens ran more West Coast/quick timing stuff, chipped Edge guys with Tight Ends, zone-blocked, used RPOs, 3 Running Backs, 3 Tight Ends, more runs in general...
Wow you think Greg Robinson did all that, really? You've already interred Desmond Harrison?
Don't get me wrong here: Greg Robinson DID do a fine job, and does not suck. But his "bar" was extremely low. He rarely had to protect for over 3 seconds, and more often than not had TE help.
You people...
Desmond Harrison has at least a 50/50 shot at a starting tackle spot, because he is physically superior to everybody else, and is dirt-cheap.
I guess my next post should be "Business 101". None of you people seem to get ANY of this.
Id
It's nice to see Captain Obvious writing about how sharp Antonio Callaway looks at the beginning of his second NFL season. Why would this be a surprise?
The writer mentions Callaway's "ups and downs" during his first, rookie season...as if that wasn't utterly predictable as well---but it's also misleading:
Callaway's "downs" (drops and no doubt bad routes) all occured early in his rookie first season, as he predictably improved game by game.
During the last few games, Callaway was integral. In the finale, he caught 4/79 vs none other than the Ravens. He drew a blank the previous week vs the Bengals (might have been injured), but the week earlier vs the Broncos he caught 5/35. I'm not certain, but don't think he dropped any, and bet he caught over 75% of his targets.
In addition to reminding yourself that Callaway was not just a rookie, but an inexperienced rookie with only a little over one year of starting experience in college, you have to remember who his OC and QB were:
None of Baker Mayfield's receivers (including OBJ) is going to dominate the NFL. As you know if you read this Blog (or have a brain of your own) one of the scariest things (for defenses) about Baker is that his favorite receiver is always the one who is the most open/deepest period.
This makes what Callaway did late in his first, rookie season with this team pretty impressive.
Jarvis Landry outperformed Callaway in those last 3 games, but not by much. His stats vs the Broncos and Ravens were remarkably similar to Callaway's in every category, and each caught nine passes in those 2 games.
Err...you GET that the guy I'm comparing Callaway to is Jarvis Landry, right?
Now, a lot of info on Callaway is garbage. He's closer to 6' tall than to 5'10", and should weigh over 200 lbs now. He was the third fastest WR in his class.
He had a crappy vertical jump, but the rest of his tests showed great explosion and "suddenness".
Going just by his game-tapes and combine numbers, he looked like a first round pick, but he was a bone-head (and a crook) and lost a lot of time in college to suspensions (and is lucky not to be in prison).
That's right: He was Dorsey's kinda guy!
And I'm sorry, folks, but that's a big part of why John Dorsey keeps "finding" players in the later rounds who kick ass. Along with taking guys with injury histories, inexperienced late bloomers, guys stuck behind superstuds etc., he takes "bad guys".
He took Kareem Hunt TWICE. Once low in the draft, and again as a street free agent. Moralize if you want (I respect it), but Mister Spock and Paul DePodesta concur with the logic.
But I digress: Antonio Callaway's upside is...well...OBJ! He's very similar to Beckham! Similar stature and physical traits. He's bookended by Landry and the aforementioned now, so trust me, he's practicing one-handed catches like those two did.
As many have pointed out, these top three WR's are all under 6' tall, but as you know if you read this, Baker Mayfield is the Browns' QB, so having skyscrapers isn't as important here.
But going from dumb to dumber, why are they saying the Browns don't have any tall wide receivers?
I know that Derrick Willies was undrafted, and his NFL sample-size prior to his season-ending injury was microscopic, but he was injured--not KILLED, ok? He's back! Give him a freaking chance, please!
Ditto Dameion Ratley; another guy who didn't play a lot in college. Look at this 6'1"!?! Closer to 6'3" why does Ourlads shrink everybody?
Anyway, in addition to his rawness, Ratley WAS also a beanpole. But you know what? HE isn't dead either!
Ratley is remarkably "sudden" for his height, and is about as fast as Callaway and OBJ.
You MM's write second year players off based on their rookie seasons. It never ceases to astonish me. Because Ratley WAS a beanpole and hardly played in his first rookie season behind Landry, Callaway, and the two RBs/2-3 TEs, he no longer even exists for many of you...WOW.
Then of course there's Rashard Higgins, who you at least remember exists.
Higgins surprised me, as I had him pegged as a "possession" guy, but he actually made several BIG plays in 2018.
But it's like I'm the only person to notice that!!! Everybody else is like "meh" in re Higgins. What does he have to do?
Anyway, even though Baker Mayfield doesn't need crutches, he has several tall WR's anyway (to go with all those tight ends).
In fact, John Dorsey might be trading Landry, OBJ, Higgins or whoever down the road apiece as Rodney Ratleyfield, Callaway, and (who knows?) Willies surprise everybody (except me...and DePodesta).
Dorsey will need to trade some players in the next couple seasons in order to keep some of the star draft picks they've piled up recently.
Jabrill Peppers was one. Duke Johnson, DeValve et al are on-deck, but don't be too shocked if a Damarius Randall or a Greg Robinson is traded.
Get up. Shake it off. If the Coaches tell John Dorsey that somebody else on this roster is ready to replace any starter whose contract expires in 2020, John Dorsey WILL trade him (if the price is right).
I'm not predicting anything here, G. Just sayin business is business, and John Dorsey is as ruthless and efficient as Lord Insideous (Belichick).
I could get deeper in the weeds and tell you how for Kitchens and Mayfield the OT's aren't as critical anymore and under Wilks a Schobert or Randall aren't critical either and talk basic math and common sense about contracts and massive---
Well if you read this you have graduated kindergarten, so you get it.
I like Beardless Baker lots more than Bearded Baker. (I will, of course, defer to female and gay opinions).
I just want to point out that there is a middle ground: You can have a short, well-trimmed beard.
But I digress: Baker Mayfield is "purty", and if he re-grows than black hedgerow, there is something wrong with him. Clean-shaven check. Mustache check. SHORT beard check. BUSH NOOOOO!!!
Sam Darnold might consider a big bushy beard. That might help Rosen too (haven't considered it much). But just in general, the less you shave or trim, the harder you are to look at.
...well unless you're demented, like I think Ryan Fitzpatrick is. No offense to Ryan...at least he's not piercing everything...
Baker just needs his teeth fixed a little, and then he's a movie star. If I were his agent, I'd have him doing commercials and stuff already (I mean with his teeth fixed).
I hope the last few paragraphs roped in a few Jerry Springer or Doctor Phil fans...
Freddie Kitchens is correct in pointing out to the unwashed masses that the Browns' DEFENSE is talented too.
Skipping schemes, Coaches, etc., the new (presumptive) starters include Oivier Vernon, Sheldon Richardson, and Morgan Burnett...and (with all due respect to Terrence Mitchell), Greedy Williams too.
Four new starters is a pretty massive turnover, especially when a new Defensive Coordinator has influenced the signings and draft picks.
Check my last several posts: I don't believe four down linemen are as important to Steve Wilks as they were to Gregg Williams.
As I've told you, Wilks' sample size as a DC was one year (with a very talented Panthers defense), and what he did as Head Coach in Arizona is fuzzy.
Most of those who predict what he will do with the 2019 Browns are guessing.
I am now pretty sure that Steve Wilks will run 3-man fronts a LOT. If any of you had the patience (or were obsessed or bored enough) to follow along with me, you'll see how the passrushing/blow-up linebackers (including 2 EDGE guys) and ZERO "nose tackle" types well...no seriously well?
...I thought so. I work very hard to talk to you. I'm on my 11th beer. But I just can't get dumb enough to communicate with you (see that? Four syllables! It's hopeless!
No no don't bring up "utilize". It means "use". The only reason anybody invented this word was to con stupid people into thinking the user of the word is smarter than he is.
Brady Quinn is actually very smart, but he keeps saying "utilize". Jeez sometimes he says "use" and then says "I mean utilize"...
Idiocracy, remember?
I know I'm supposed to stick with Browns stuff here, but I can't help resisting the idiocracy...I just can't stifle myself...
Nevermind okbye.
First, this Tampa Bay writer got several things wrong as he jumped on the McCoy Madness Motorcade:
1: The "talk" coming out of Cleveland is coming from (less brilliant/humble) guys like me, and not the team.
2: There was never a "five year plan" for the Browns. No sane GM has ever tried a "five year plan" since the advent of free agency, and the notion got even more idiotic with the rookie salary structure.
The rookie contracts are for four years. Only first rounders come with fifth year options. Invariably, the best of the young players become very expensive before their rookie deals expire, and teams often lose them, as, at some other point in the past, somebody also cut down the money tree and replaced it with a salary cap.
Paul DePodesta's original plan was much longer-term than we've seen in the NFL for some time, but the rebuilding phase was two years, after which he expected them to contend for the playoffs.
You get this, right? Ideally, by year 3 they have a viable Quarterback, their first draft class has some experience, and now is the time to spend some of the money they've been hoarding on proven veteran free agents.
I may be being unfair to this writer (who is not a dumbass-hence the link), as I suppose you could reasonably expect it to take five years for any crappy team to reach a Superbowl...but that's not how DePodesta thinks, or what people call "analytics" does either.
...that's complicated, and I won't bore you (more). But generally speaking, the lengths of the rookie contracts and the "miss"-rates on draft picks make five years way too vague and shaky.
Also, the history of many, many Superbowl teams says that more often than not, teams other than the Patiots go from the dumster to the Big game in 2-4 years.
But this writer is correct that DePodesta's long-term plan was accellerated massively due to Baker Mayfield's instant emergence as a top ten quarterback.
DePodesta couldn't count on any such thing in year 3.
True Franchise Quarterbacks are rare, and this Fortune 500 business consultant never counted on ever having one.
All of his early plans were predicated on building a strong TEAM (much more predictable with the best personnel people), and having a "solid" quarterback ("game manager") by year 3.
He was right on schedule when John Dorsey replaced Sashi Brown prior to the 2018 season...
Okay here I have to ask some questions about the 2017 Draft: Hue Jackson had the right to pick his own QB written into his contract.
He had the authority to override Sashi Brown.
When he said "You'll have to trust me on this one" in re Cody Kessler he was defending HIS pick, Mary Kay. Not "taking one for the team" (I still can't believe MKC wrote that crap).
I know, DePodesta said they didn't think Wentz could be a top 20 QB, but he said "we", and he was NOT a "football guy". DePodesta was NEVER here to pick players.
God am I the only guy left who understands english? DePodesta repeatedly said that analyitics was one of several "tools" to help evaluate players, and never spoke in the first person.
I STRONGLY suspect that DePodesta relied on Hue Jackson in re Quarterbacks when he made that idiotic statement.
On a purely anaytical level, you see, Wentz was a prototype NFL Quarterback, as PFF, Numberfire, etc stipulated.
But Quarterbacks are different. So much is mental and psychological. Many, many "prototypes" crap out.
Do any of you people understand that Paul Depodesta was never here to pick individual players in the first place? That his drafts were never based on analytics; that the scouts and Coaches still had the loudest voice? That DePodesta KNEW his own limitations, and deferred to these professionals in re specific players?
Nah. You never got any of that.
Anyhow, Kessler, Kizer, and RG III were all HUE JACKSON guys!!!
Here comes John Dorsey, who had one year earlier traded up do draft Pat Mahomes.
Nobody could believe that Hue Jackson (1-31) hadn't been fired. (I explained that. As preposterous as it sounds, the PR fallout off yet another early HC termination would have been even worse than his retention of a 1-31 Coach.)
But also, Jackson was neutered. Todd Haley was brought in to replace him (utterly) as OC, and he couldn't override him. Effectively, Hue Jackson was a figurehead in his final season with the Browns...
And by the way, the language in his contract which gave him authority to pick quarterbacks wasn't worth the paper it was written on. If he made a stink, he would be fired.
Anyway, Dorsey came in and did what he did.
Wow: Kizer for Randall? Then Mayfield instead of those other guys? Then the--nevermind, but all very impressive.
But I digress: Mayfield is the game-changer here:
Baker Mayfield is unmistakeably a Franchise Quarterback.
Because the rest of the team is loaded from top to bottom with talent, Paul 100% concurs with John Dorsey that they should go for all the marbles in 2019...but...
3: I'm not sure about John Dorsey, but Chief STRATEGY Officer Paul DePodesta is in Jimmy Haslam's ear, and Jimmy is listening:
As it stands (see my previous posts), (and I apolologize for redundantationalizing again), the last THREE Browns' drafts have been really good, and included 6 first rounders.
NOW, one of those picks is a Superstar Quarterback.
Paul DePodesta (and the Haslams) want the Browns to be like the Patriots (*I never said "will be"...nor did OBJ*).
I personally don't think John Dorsey is a spazz, like everybody else does. In fact, it looks to me like he and Paul DePodesta get along fine.
To date, all his trades have made financial and long-term sense.
No doubt, Dorsey would love to have Gerald McCoy, but he's 31.
This Tampa writer naturally wants the Bucs to get something in exchange for Gerald McCoy, but is being unrealistic.
McCoy is coming off a strong, productive season. He's healthy, and has been durable throughout his carreer. He will not accept a 50+% pay cut to facilitate a trade to a team that would make him a rotational player.
The Bucs will have to cut him. Dorsey will be in the mad scramble to sign him, but DePodesta will "cut off the bidding"--and McCoy probably won't become a Brown.
Sorry to put you through all this for a bad ending, but welcome to my world!
However, as I've said (a lot) DT depth may not be the as urgent a need as most think it is, as Steve Wilks is not Gregg Williams, and definitely influenced this offseason.
...still with me here?
The only DT Dorsey drafted was...Ok but the Free Agent DT was...ok I got nothing here.
Critical thinking 101: WHY?
Obviously, Steve Wilks likes linebackers and secondary player more than DT's.
Critical Thinking 102 gets into the specific Defensive players drafted (or signed):
We can eliminate Greedy Williams. He's overbashed as a tackler, but was one of the 2 best man corners in this class.
Both linebackers were good in coverage, and Takitaki was a converted DE who blows things up (he's like Rodney Averyfield).
Critical Thinking 103: The Browns now have (at least) 2 OLB's who are edge-rushers; one of which can put his hand in the dirt.
Ok (sigh) long story short: Steve Wilks is more comfortable with 3-4's than Gregg Williams was.
If you had a clue, you'd be laughing at that joke now, but I will explain:
Some form of nickel. or dime defense is on the field about 69% nowadays, so this 3-4, 4-3 stuff is a joke.
Stay with me here: Steve Wilks was a DC for exactly one season before he was made a Head Coach. Everybody who "pegs" him (as a "type of" DC) based on that is guessing.
I don't guess. Critical thinking 104: Steve Wilks will mix 3 and 4-man down-lineman fronts (sort of a technicality, really, since if Avery or Takitaki is in your face, they are in your face).
Williams aside, the rest of the defensive draft picks are good vs the run.
Wilks was a Head Coach for one (horrific) season, but he was hired as one for reasons. I have a hunch that Steve Wilks will be at least a competent Defensive Coordinator for the 2019 Browns.
You people (ie MKC and everybody else) crack me up when you try to analyze coaches.
Wilks was a secondary coach, ergo Linebackers and Defensive Linemen need not apply? He will run the identical defense to the one he ran in his one season as the Panthers' DC?
In reality, nobody (including me) has a bead on Steve Wilks 2019.
But you know me! Glass half-full! Consensus expert opinion (but what do they know?)
No I can definitively tell you this: Steve Wilks has never had as much talent to play with as he has now. He may never have had as much influence over a draft as he had in 2019 (I think).
Wilks could be an idiot, for all I know (after all, Dorsey hired Todd Haley), but glass half full...
Actually more than that:
Wilks has a clear agenda, as indicated by the 2019 draft and UFDA class...
Nothing new here. I'm just Captain Obvious here: The 2019 Browns have one of the 5 best secondaries in the NFL, AND a top 5 passrush, so........
Budd wudd aboud...
Steve Doerschuk is out of his rubber room, as he wrote a much more sane article on the Browns' rumored or assumed interest in DT Gerald McCoy, but he still doesn't get some things:
1: The Browns are not in good cap shape, as a bunch of us have been explaining for several weeks.
The big one is, of course, Baker Mayfield, and yes, John Dorsey does have to start saving his pennies and planning now to retain him, because he will command a king's ransom in '22 or '23.
Bill Polian said "the longer you wait, the more it will cost you", which is why Dorsey might want to get Baker's long-term second contract done early (in '21 or '22).
It means paying top QB money well before you have to, so in the short term it hurts a lot, but in the long run it makes your stud quarterback comparatively cheap over the balance of his contract.
Polian et al would also tell you: The Quarterback naturally wants moe munnah sooner, and long-term security (in case of carreer-ending injury or whatever), and will happily accept being the highest-paid QB in football in a given year.
After all, if he rode out his rookie contract, he'd earn a fraction of that money for 1-2 seasons (and like I said is "covered" if his carreer ends prematurely).
The QB will be amedable to a longer-term deal (ie 6 years or longer) under these circumstances.
You younger people have been taught that somebody wins and somebody loses in every commercial exchange, but that is Marxist propaganda. This is one example:
The Quarterback gets a huge raise and security early. The team(/insurer) locks up a critical asset long-term to a contract which inflation will render more affordable sooner as caps and salaries continue to grow.
Nobody is screwing or oppressing anybody, see? And that is what capitalism really is, comrade!
But I digress: DePodesta will probably push for this "nip it in the bud" approach to the elephant in the room (ie the Franchise Quarterback's looming and swelling massive, crippling, inescapable raise).
Nah. I'm not "assuming" too much at all. If you expect this specific Quarterback in this specific context to take a step back in season 2, you are clueless.
Baker Mayfield, eyeball-deep in weapons, will make himself much more expensive in 2019 and 2020. He WILL command moe munnah than the highest-paid QB in the NFL.
This is the market, folks. Even if he's really the 4th or 5th best QB, his agent will want top money, and they usually get it.
Remember the Kirk Cousins fiasco? Cousins wasn't the best QB in the NFL by any stretch, but there you go! (And the Vikings didn't win the Superbowl for some mysterious reason) but I digress again:
Here again is the list of Browns 2020 free agents.
Budgeting for Baker Mayfield...who by the way is a Quarterback, which is different...John Dorsey has to start planning and saving now.
Otherwise smart people like Doerschuk still can't think 2 years down the road. Either that, or they think that a chance at a Superbowl appearance right now is worth flushing the salary cap and draft picks down the terlet.
I remember thinking like these people. Imagine Gerald McCoy in that DT rotation. How awesome that would be! And this guy is a character guy, and a leader too!
I want him! Wilks must want him too! He's over 30, but has been durable and kicked ass in 2018 as usual. Cut his reps down in this rotation to keep him fresh and healthy wow...I want him!
But most likely, one of the other 31 teams will land McCoy.
Look: ONE of the wild, gossipy, Soap-Operish speculations about the Browns is almost certainly accidentally accurate, because it's obvious:
Chief Strategy Officer Paul DePodesta is still here, and is still "in Haslam's ear".
As horrible as that sounds...well you just aren't very bright if it sounds horrible to you:
The biggest single reason for the KC Chief's termination of John Dorsey (actually the only possible one--aside from politics) was his (allegedly) poor cap management (no comment I dunno aint checked it out yet).
Ok well, even if Dorsey actually agreed with the speculations and rumors and is desperate to get McCoy (and not Suh or any of 3-5 other already free agents), he won't be allowed to do anything stupid.
And I LOVE that!
In fairness to John Dorsey, I don't yet know exactly why the Chiefs fired him, and just know that "cap abuse" seems the most viable legitimate reason.
At any rate, whether or not Dorsey is the reckless spender he's accused of being, I LOVE that Paul DePodesta is still here.
If the Browns sign Gerald McCoy, it will be for less money than Doerschuk or most others expect.
That's unlikely. The Cleveland Browns will NOT overpay him. Somebody else probably will.
There is a chance here, as McCoy isn't like Suh character-wise. McCoy might possibly accept less money for the chance to win a Superbowl (and prolong his carreer as a rotational player).
Suh won't be a Cleveland Brown. He cares only about money. I'm glad he's off the table. He's despicable...
But I digress: Doerschuk is around the bend on this McCoy stuff, and should "diversify", because it probably won't happen.
Sam Penix lists 5 Browns players he thinks are on the bubble in 2019.
First, I want credit for not exploiting Sam's last name...
Anyway, Sam nailed most of them.
Greg Joseph is obvious, as Dorsey drafted a kicker.
Sam thinks Dameion Ratley is in trouble too, but I think he's wrong:
Much like Greedy Williams this year, Ratley wasa beanpole in his draft class. He did nothing in 2018 with Landry, Callaway, Higgins, Duke Johnson etc in front of him.
But Ratley should come back at over 200 lbs and remain tall, shifty, and sure-handed...
Ratley is UNlikely to be cut loose (unless he is an ass-hat and squanders his talent.) Dameion Ratley is around 6'2" and darts and dashes around like he's 5'10".
Writing Ratley off already is premature, as he has LETHAL tools.
Seth DeValve is on the bubble too (Sam got this one right). It sucks, because DeValve is a really good player. If not for Njoku, Seth would have started at TE, and kicked ass (again).
Obviously, John Dorsey is trying to trade DeValve now, while he has value.
Chris Smith check: He's an older player with an inflated salary. Dorsey signed him prior to the 2018 draft...why don't you get that
Oh you people! "Why wood he trade dommazz avvder he paidd himm erroyyy?"
*"domazz"=Thomas I'm fonetic here*. Dorsey nabbed Thomas cheap ahead of the 2018 draft. Then drafted Thomas...who he no doubt likes better
But Sam missed badly here, as he skipped all the high profile 2020 free agents, and ignored the future... Starting with 2020.
I'm sick of superficial, shallow, emotional, knee-jerk, spastic "analysisis" lumping Mayfield in with everybody else, Dorsey, Kitchens, and this ROSTER in with...
Oh for cryin out loud how tf can you listen to Colon Cowherd? How can you NOT see the talent and COACHING here?
And oh yes:
The Ratbirds are all insulted and stuff. They won the Division in 2018. Why shouldn't they win it again in 2019?
DON'T GET ME STARTED.
The Steelers are likewise offended by seemingly everybody favoring the Browns over them.
Too bad. Big Ben is a probable HOF QB, but Baker Mayfield is already BETTER than he is!
Hear that? Baker Mayfield IS better than Roethsenberger...NOW.
More on this later...but for now, I will have fun imagining the hysteria.
Big Ben vs Mayfield (snort-snicker) ? Inconceivable, right?
Grow up. Think with your brain. Trust your eyes. Big Ben's history is irrelevant. IMO, Baker Mayfield is better than Big Ben NOW.
OBJ concurs with me...
Okbye